by Texas Homesteader
A few weeks ago I started playing with recipes for making my own healthier fudgesicles. I used RancherMan as a very willing guinea pig for several batches until I perfected it.
Taste-Testing Homemade Fudgesicles? RancherMan’s got a tough job, huh? Poor guy!
I wanted to make my own fudgesicles for several reasons: They’re healthier, filled with probiotics, produce less landfill trash, are much less expensive. Plus, c’mon let’s be honest – it’s EASY!
Aaaahhhh, summer fun. Picnics, swimming, baseball and cookouts. Who doesn’t love summer?
But summer in Texas also means hot, hot, HOT! Of course living & working on a Homestead means that RancherMan & I work outside during these dog days of summer. So we’re always looking for ways to keep cool.
Fudgesicle Recipe Trial & Error
I wanted to use my homemade yogurt as the base for these fudgesicles. And I wanted natural honey for the sweetener. So I set out to experiment with the balance.
The first attempt at homemade fudgesicles was waaaaay too sweet (and prepare yourself for this) way too chocolate.
Whaaaa…??? Is it even POSSIBLE for something to be TOO chocolate??
Stay with me now – although I love all things chocolate, the cocoa was so overpowering that even though the fudgesicles were too sweet the cocoa made the popsicle almost bitter.
2nd Attempt For Perfect Fudgesicle
The second batch was better, but the flavor of the yogurt was a little too prominent for my taste.
And although the cocoa proportion was improved I also wanted more intensity in the actual chocolate flavor.
Hummm… back to the drawing board I go.
3rd Time’s A Charm!
Then there was batch 3 – and we’ve got a winner!
RancherMan declares that these are not as icy as previous batches, more creamy and with a good balance of sweet & chocolate.
Here’s what I did:
Best Fudgesicle Recipe
When making these fudgesicles I like to mix everything together in a large 4-cup measuring cup. It just makes everything easier since it already has a handle and pouring spout.
🌱 Save 5% on premium raised garden beds with coupon code TXH5OFF.
So I start out by mixing the cocoa & yogurt together first. I feel the yogurt helps blend the powdery cocoa more thoroughly.
I need a cup of yogurt. But since I make my homemade yogurt in 1/2-pint canning jars (which measures 1 cup) I don’t even need to measure the yogurt. So I just plop it into the bowl with the cocoa and get to blending.
After the yogurt & cocoa are thoroughly combined I simply refill the yogurt jar with skim milk to get a 1-cup measure & add it in.
Finally I add the other ingredients into my bowl. There’s honey from our own apiary for a natural sweetener, vanilla extract for flavor and coffee to intensify the chocolate flavor.
Oooh really?? Chocolate AND coffee in the same recipe? Oh my, I’m in heaven!
Now all that’s left to do is mix until it’s all thoroughly combined. Yeah, you can see how I slave in the kitchen for this cold summer treat. But that’s just me – I’m a giver!
Pouring Fudgesicle Into Molds
As I mentioned, I already have a convenient pouring spout on my measuring cup. So pouring the fudgesicle mixture into my popsicle molds is a snap.
After they are all filled I just place the molds in the freezer until they’re frozen. 
Then all that’s left to do is freeze them & ENJOY! Sometimes it’s hard for me to wait, patience isn’t really one of my virtues.
But wait I will. And this chocolate treat is worth the wait let me tell ya.
Simple. Healthy. Inexpensive.
I love that I can give RancherMan the sweet cold treat he craves. Plus it’s much healthier than store-bought versions since it uses wholesome ingredients and is sweetened with honey.
Depending upon the size of your popsicle molds (which vary widely) you can make 6-10 fudgesicles and I’ve shared my recipe below.
But I typically want to make more at one time so they’re ready and waiting on us. So I also doubled the recipe to make more fudgesicles. Depending upon the size of your popsicle molds, this will make between 15-20 fudgesicles!
Without further adieu – my slaving-in-the-kitchen doubled homemade fudgesicle recipe follows.
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Mix all together in a mixing bowl until thoroughly blended. Carefully pour into popsicle molds and place in the freezer for 3-4 hours until frozen. ENJOY!
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!And The Doubled Recipe:
Homemade Healthier Fudgesicles (fills 12-16 popsicle molds)
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Mix all together in a mixing bowl until thoroughly blended. Carefully pour into popsicle molds and place in the freezer for 3-4 hours until frozen. ENJOY!
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!~TxH~
Snacks We Love
- Homemade Honey-Graham Crackers
- Fresh Pico de Gallo
- Homemade Hummus
- Rosemary Crackers w/Olive Oil & Garlic
- MYO Pita Chips Using Flour Tortillas
- Pumpkin Bread (with Cake-Mix Shortcut)
- Cantaloupe Bread w/Pecan Praline Glaze
- Easy Blueberry Muffins
- Fresh Pear Cake
- Rice Krispie Treats With A Chocolate Twist
- Healthier ‘Ice Cream’ Using Bananas & Fruit
- Easy Cookies-n-Cream Ice Cream Cake
- Easiest 3-Ingredient Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe
- Cake-Mix Cookies – Only 3 Ingredients!
- Double Chocolate Banana Chunk Cookies
- Sugar-Free Chocolate No-Bake Cookies
- Triple Chocolate Truffles
- Getting Your Family To Snack On Healthy Veggies
- Watermelon Smoothie (or Daiquiri)
- …And MANY MORE!
See All Recipe Posts
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
C’mon by & sit a spell! Come hang out at our Facebook Page. It’s like sitting in a front porch rocker with a glass of cold iced tea – lots of good folks sharing! You can also follow along on Pinterest, Twitter or Instagram.
If you’d like to receive an email each time a new blog post goes live it’s EASY to
Subscribe to our blog!
16 Responses
These sound so good I must make them. Thanks for sharing at What’d You Do This Weekend.
Linda
Oh the hardships our husbands must endure for those busy hands in the kitchen. This sounds like a great recipe and one I would like to try. Have you tried making these with sugar or a sugar-free sweetener? My husband is allergic to honey. 🙁 It was great meeting you this Wednesday! I’m now following you.
I’ve only used honey Cathy. I try to take about a tablespoon of local honey each day for seasonal allergies, I usually mix it into my morning yogurt. Although I make my own yogurt, I’m now making it twice as often because RancherMan’s so fond of these fudgesicles. And hey, I guess I’m still having my yogurt & honey, just having it frozen with a little cocoa! LOL
Hi Tammy
I just stopped by from the Wonderful Wednesday Blog Hop – this is the second of your posts that I have clicked on! I am glad to have found your website – following it on Google+ now. My post today is a farm memory as well – of my grandparents farm in Pennsylvania. And guess what – their last name was Taylor!
You had me won with the addition of coffee. These sound great. I use to make my own Popsicles many years ago. Might give it a go again.
You had me at cocoa. I love fudgesicles but most of the knock-offs you find just don’t taste as good as the originals. I’ll have to try these.
Hello fellow Texan! It’s blazing hot down here near the Texas Gulf Coast. I am in Victoria. I have made popsicles but never tried making fudgesicles. Thanks for your recipe. I will give it a try!
Big Texas Hugs,
Susan and Bentley
I had those same popsicle molds. I bought a few and broke them all. LOL Thanks for linking at #stoptheyuck and I hope to see you again this week.
I have a 6-pk of the Tupperware popsicle molds and I *LOVE* them, but the fudgesicle recipe I was working with made about 12 fudgesicles so I had to go out & buy some cheap ones to see me through. I was pretty disappointed with the performance of these (but they are pretty and make for a great picture!) I’m currently looking for more of the TupperWare sets but they’re not made anymore so I’m searching in garage sales, etc.
I have all these ingredients right now I can ‘t wait to try this. We’ve been loving anything sweet and cold this summer so I’m glad to see this. Now following on FB and sharing on my FB page and pinning!
I think I’ll take my morning coffee in fudgesicle form in the morning! These sound yummy!
What a super simple yet tasty recipe? It is winter time here in Australia however I can’t wait to try this recipe when it warms up – pinned for future reference! Stopping by from the party over at What’s on the List
really like these.
Like Goldilocks, it looks like the 3rd one was the perfect recipe =) Thank you for your scrumptious and healthy fudgesicles. (Stopping by from the What’s On the List party.)
These are just the kind of recipes we like! Chocolatey but healthy (if possible ~ smile). I have saved this! Thank you for sharing this week on the Art of Home-Making Mondays at Strangers & Pilgrims on Earth! 🙂
Looks amazing! So yummy! #overthemoon