Easier Homemade Dill Pickles From Garden Cucumbers

by Texas Homesteader ~ 
* contains affiliate link 

We love dill pickles but I’ve never been happy making my own brine. I’ve found the secret weapon – a SUPER EASY brine. Making homemade pickles has never been THIS easy! Check it out.

We love dill pickles but I've never been happy making my own brine. I've found the secret weapon - a SUPER EASY brine. Check it out. #TexasHomesteader

(Note: Some links in this post are for further information from earlier posts I’ve written. But links preceded with * are affiliate links. If you click them and buy something (almost anything, not just the item noted) I could receive a small commission. But the price you pay will NOT change. It’s an easy way to support this blog without anything coming out of your pocket. So click often! Thank you!)

Garden Gift Of Fresh Cucumbers

Recently I was given a handful of cucumbers from the veggie garden of a sweet friend.

RancherMan won’t eat cucumbers any other way but pickled. And a girl can only eat so many raw cucumbers. So instead I set out to preserve them.

I use dill pickles often in deviled eggs, making pickle relish and in other dishes but especially in  my homemade ham salad,

Homemade ham salad using smoked ham. #TexasHomesteader

So the decision as to what to do with these cucumbers was easy for me – make DILL PICKLES!

Secret For Making Great Dill Pickles Easily!

Now I’ve made pickles completely from scratch on a few occasions. But I’ve never been pleased with the results. 

The finished pickles were often soft, even when using special pickling cucumber varieties. And the brine (no matter what recipe I used) was always too strong or with not enough herb flavor for my tastes.

But one day I happened to be visiting a family member who had grown & pickled  cucumbers from his garden. He offered a taste of his finished pickles and I loved them! 

I asked what his secret was and he whispered “Mrs. Wages“.

I had never even heard of Mrs. Wages. So he described the package to me and I went looking for it.  (by the way I found that you can get various flavors of * Mrs Wages Pickling Mix from Amazon

I gave the Mrs. Wages dill pickle mix a try using our own cucumbers. OMGosh y’all, finally SUCCESS!  That’s the only way I’ll make dill pickles from now on.

We love dill pickles but I've never been happy making my own brine. I've found the secret weapon - a SUPER EASY brine. Check it out. #TexasHomesteader

How To Prepare Cucumbers For Pickling

So now that I have a supply of cucumbers to pickle from my friend’s garden, I washed & dried the cucumbers and cut about 1/4″ off each end. (I’ve read that if you don’t cut off the bloom end it can lead to soft pickles.)

I didn’t know what variety of cucumbers these were since they were gifts. So they may or may not have been actual pickling cucumbers.

When To Harvest Cucumbers For Pickling

Some of my friend’s cucumbers were harvested a bit large for pickling. If you’ll be making pickles with your cucumbers you usually want to pick them when they’re still slender and the skin is dark green & bumpy. 

Fresh garden cucumbers with dark green skin and small bumps are perfect for pickling. #TexasHomesteader

A large, pale green or yellow cucumber with a smooth surface is usually a little too mature to result in a really great pickle.

Can You Use Large Mature Cucumbers For Pickling?

Cucumbers that have grown larger are not ideal for pickling. That’s because:

      • Larger cucumbers have usually formed tougher seeds inside.

      • Skin of larger cucumbers is often tough.

      • Larger cucumbers often have a bitter taste.

But larger cucumbers were what I was gifted from my friend. So for those larger cucumbers I figured I had nothing to lose.

Preparing Larger Cucumbers For Pickling

I tasted a slice off of each of those larger cucumbers to make sure they were not bitter. If they were still mild tasting I went ahead & used them for my pickles.

It was easy to peel them if the skins were tough or remove the seed section from each cut cucumber spear which had already formed larger seeds.

I washed & dried my jars and heated water for my canning lids. The flat disk of the 2-part canning lid was placed into the hot water to soften the rubber seal & then I went to work on the preparations. 

Now the cucumbers were all cut up – some with the seed section cut out, some peeled, some just sliced into spears. I packed them snugly into my clean canning jars.

Using Mrs. Wages To Make Dill Pickles

Then I mixed up the Mrs. Wages mix per the package directions and got the mixture boiling, stirring constantly. 

I poured the hot mix into the jars packed with cucumber wedges, leaving about 1/2″ from the top of the jar. A rubber spatula was used to remove any trapped air bubbles between the cucumbers.

If needed, I topped off the liquid in the jar to maintain 1/2″ headspace between the top of the liquid and the rim of the jar.

I don’t like to process my pickles using a water-bath canner, as I’m concerned that may be one of the reasons my pickles were always soft before.

So I wiped the rim of each jar, screwed on the 2-part canning lid and turned the hot jars upside down on a clean kitchen towels.  

This procedure typically seals the lid fine overnight, then I can store them in the fridge.

Pickle Canning Safety Message:

I MUST say here that I’m not recommending that you skip the canning process, I’m  just showing what I did with these cucumbers. I figure back in ‘the day’ they made pickles by soaking raw cucumbers in brine in big crocks in the cellar, so it must be the brine itself that preserves the cucumbers.  This time I decided not to put my cucumbers through the water-bath canning process. BUT you’ll need to read the USDA’s recommendations on safe canning and decide for yourself.

Anyway I let the dill pickles sit in the brine for about 3 weeks to allow the pickling process to continue. The resulting dill pickles were delicious! 

Although they were tasty, since they apparently weren’t pickling cucumbers they were still softer than we like for snacking. But I still put them to good use.

They are great chopped into sandwich spreads like our homemade Egg Salad or even deviled eggs.

Fresh egg salad made from eggs from our backyard chickens and homemade pickles and sweet relish. #TexasHomesteader

UPDATE:  In subsequent years I planted heirloom pickler cucumbers and I use them with this Mrs. Wages mix. They always turn out GREAT! 

Tips For Crisp Homemade Pickles

There are several tips I’ve read over the years to make help you make crisp homemade pickles:

  • Use cucumber varieties grown for pickling. I like *Pickler Cucumbers.

  • Fresher cucumbers make crisper pickles. Harvest right before pickling.

  • Younger cucumbers make better pickles. Harvest when small, dark green and bumpy skin.

  • Cut about 1/4″ of the blossom end off the cucumber. That’s said to remove the enzymes that make for soggy pickles.

  • Add a fresh grape leaf to each jar if possible. I read that including a leaf from a grapevine right inside your jar will help keep the pickles crisp.

Concord grapevine leaves. #TexasHomesteader

Now I don’t know if using a fresh grape leaf is an old wives’ tale or not. But using all the tips above to make homemade pickles crisp have always been successful for me. 

So if you’d like to make your own homemade pickles, give Ms. Wages mix a try for your brine. Homemade pickles really couldn’t be simpler!


This post categorized in        

Tagged in All our posts about food preservation - dehydrating, canning, freezing, etc. #TexasHomesteader  Our favorite homemade seasoning mixes. #TexasHomesteader A list of our simple homemade condiment recipes. #TexasHomesteader A list of our posts about cooking with the garden's harvest. #TexasHomesteader   A list of all our gardening posts. #TexasHomesteader


Preserving The Harvest Posts

…And Much MORE!

See All Preserving The Harvest Posts

C’mon by & sit a spell!  Come hang out at our Facebook Page. It’s like sitting in a front porch rocker with a glass of cold iced tea – lots of good folks sharing!  You can also follow along on Pinterest, Twitter or Instagram.

If you’d like to receive an email each time a new blog post goes live it’s EASY to
Subscribe to our blog!

*Amazon affiliate









17 thoughts on “Easier Homemade Dill Pickles From Garden Cucumbers

  1. Helen at the Lazy Gastronome

    I used to can dozens of pickles when my kids were at home!! Now I just do a jar or two for me and hubby. Thanks for sharing on the What’s for Dinner link up.

  2. Katy SkipTheBag

    My whole goal for planing cucumber is to be able to make pickles. Sadly I don’t think my cukes are going to make it (dang caterpillars!). I really want to ferment them, but if that doesn’t work out I’ll be sure to check this out! It’s always good to have a back up method. Thanks for sharing on the Waste Less Wednesday Hop!

  3. Alicia Owen

    I think that’s what my husband used to make his pickles too. It’s our first year and we haven’t tried them yet. Actually, I won’t be trying them at all because I hate pickles, but I hope they turned out for him! ha ha

  4. Lisa @ Fun Money Mom

    You always have the best tips! I’ve never made pickles but always wanted to try! Thanks for linking up with us at Share The Wealth Sunday!

  5. Lisa M

    My pickles never turn out how I’d like them to! I’m definitely trying this!

    You post was featured at Green Thumb Thursday this week. Stop by and grab a featured badge for your blog! I hope to see you again this week!


  6. Chele

    You can also find Mrs Wages canning products at most Walmarts too. I love their seasoning for dill pickles. But I also came to the same conclusion that the hot water bath was quickly turning them to mush. So, now I just jar them up and put them in the fridge. I haven’t tried your flipped jars for pickles. I do that method with my jams/jellies, so I’ll definitely try it with the pickles next summer. Thanks!

  7. Jamie | anderson + grant

    These look so good. I’m going to have to file this one away for next summer. I had a friend who “donated” cucumbers to me over the summer and like you, there are only so many raw ones I can eat. He thought I needed them to be healthy. Love the thought, but I thought I was already healthy!

  8. Kara @ Home With Purpose

    We love homemade dill pickles here and put up as many as we can every year! We don’t do the water bath canning, we ferment them the old-fashioned way, and our secret for making them crunchy is to put a few oak, blackberry, or grape leaves in each jar. The tannins in the leaves make the pickles crisp and crunchy! Thanks for linking up at Simple Lives Thursday!

  9. CTY

    I have not tried the Mrs Wages Dill mix because I make refrigerator pickles that taste just like Claussen (if you know that brand). I have however, used Mrs Wages Bread & Butter Pickle mix & it is perfect for sandwiches. When I had an uber harvest of zucchinis I turned them into b & b pickles–they came out fabulously.

    1. Texas Homesteader Post author

      Ummmm…. zucchini pickles. I love when you can make a great product out of garden overage like that. D’ya think you could make them into dill pickles as well? Do they taste similar when pickled as cucumbers? Inquiring minds want to know.

  10. Cynthia L

    I made pickles last year and we are still eating them. I never tried it this way though! Thanks for linking to the In and Out of the Kitchen party!

  11. Linda @ A La Carte

    I do love dill pickles! I’ll keep this in mind if I ever get a bunch of cuc’s!! Thanks for sharing at TTF!

  12. Jeannie Marie & Company

    I don’t make pickles anymore but my daughter still does. I’ll forward the blog so she can see your secret ingredient!

  13. Mel

    We’re planning on trying some pickled cucumbers if we get a good yield this year.

  14. Madge @ The View From Right Here

    LOVE homemade pickles… I haven’t made any in years… I used to put by much of summer/fall harvest, but then began working again 15 years ago and it all fell by the wayside… I just retired and am looking forward to doing all of these things again… sewing, baking, canning… oh yes, and cleaning the deep way… thanks for the inspiration!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

* Please enter the Biggest Number

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.